"How do I Know Thee: A Simulation Study of Direct and Third Party Information on Social Network Evolution" ABSTRACT Granovetter (1985) challenged traditional views of the analysis of cooperation. He claims that most approaches are either under- socialized (peers play no role) or over-socialized (institutions and central authorities play an overwhelming role). In this study we pursue the consequences of cooperation embeddeded in a social context on the evolution of social networks. We identify two strongly distinct patterns of social networks. Most surprisingly, we find that strong commitments to using social sources of information generate group polarization, while strong commitments to information arising from individual experience lead to integration among groups. Given that many studies of cooperation assume the structures in which actors function, this work helps to identify the micro-behaviors that create the structures that constrain or enable cooperation.